By Anil Merani: Fan reviews for “Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad,” the Star Plus series that premiered yesterday are generally positive, even though they are limited based on early feedback from platforms like X. Here’s a summary of user sentiments:
Positive Feedback:
Viewers have praised the show’s vibrant and lively tone, with one fan describing it as “so vibrant, so full of life and quite chaotic,” appreciating its energetic storytelling.
The chemistry between the leads, Abrar Qazi (Uday Veer) and Afia Tayebali (Katha), has been a standout feature, with fans enjoying their dynamic and the show’s fresh, youth-centric approach. This captivating chemistry is likely to keep viewers invested in the series. Specific elements, such as Uday’s dance performance and his persona as a chef, were also well-received, with one user noting they liked his “recipe” and overall vibe.
Additionally, the positive portrayal of supporting characters, like the mami who treats Katha like her own daughter, was appreciated among viewers.
One SM user rated the premiere episode 9/10, comparing it to a nostalgic Hindi college film, indicating strong engagement with the narrative and Abrar Qazi’s performance.
Criticisms:
Some users expressed disappointment with certain aspects, such as Katha’s superstitious beliefs, which felt inconsistent with her character.
The pacing of the story, particularly the rapid progression towards a marriage plot in the first episode, received criticism for feeling rushed.
One user on a forum voiced skepticism about the show’s potential, noting Star Plus’s track record with remakes (it’s an adaptation of the Bengali show “Kothha”), though this was more of a speculative remark than a direct critique of the aired episode.
A comment on a discussion board highlighted a dislike for the female lead’s portrayal in the promo, although this was made before the show aired, so it may not reflect actual reception of the episode.
Overall, user reviews tend to be positive, emphasizing the show’s fresh energy, strong performances, and cultural authenticity, although some viewers have reservations about the pacing and certain character quirks.